Data Disrespect

The numbers do not care about your team

NFLSeptember 22, 2026

NFL QB Performance Rankings: Week 2

All 34 quarterbacks with a meaningful sample, by what their plays were worth. Sortable by grade, tier, trend and availability.

Kirk Cousins stands on the field in a black Raiders jersey, number 8, clenching a fist after a play.

Every quarterback with a meaningful sample this season, ranked by what his plays were actually worth.

What the number means

Zero is league average. The grade is built from this season's play-by-play and measures every dropback outside garbage time three ways: whether the play actually helped the team score, how accurate the throw was for its difficulty, and whether it moved the chains rather than just occasionally going deep. Efficiency carries most of the weight, accuracy and consistency the rest.

Quarterbacks with few attempts are pulled toward average, in proportion to how little they have thrown. One good half does not make a number one.

Jaxson Dart is no longer on this board. He is out for the season, and a weekly performance ranking has nothing left to say about a quarterback who will not play again. Jameis Winston takes over in New York.

A single game of five or fewer dropbacks that ends with the quarterback leaving hurt is dropped entirely — too small to mean anything, and it usually includes the play the injury happened on. That is why Kyler Murray is absent: his only appearance this season was five plays ended by a concussion. He has cleared protocol and starts in Week 3, but there is nothing to grade him on yet.

Tiers are buckets of the grade, nothing more: S is 35 and up, A is 15 to 34, B is 0 to 14, C is −1 to −15, and D is below −15. Trend compares the most recent game to the season rate. Week 3 is availability as of the morning of Sept. 22.

These rankings reflect how each quarterback has played in the games measured so far — not career value, draft stock, or who is the better long-term quarterback. Two games is a small sample and it will move.

All 34

1Brock Purdy49ersS+40.92Yes
2Dak PrescottCowboysS+36.02Yes
3Drew LockSeahawksA+31.92Darnold's return unresolved
4Josh AllenBillsA+28.52Yes
5Bryce YoungPanthersA+25.02Yes
6Geno SmithJetsA+23.02Yes
7Jalen HurtsEaglesA+20.72Yes
8Matthew StaffordRamsA+20.72Yes
9Lamar JacksonRavensA+20.12Yes
10Trevor LawrenceJaguarsA+19.02Yes
11Kirk CousinsRaidersA+17.62Yes
12Caleb WilliamsBearsB+11.52game-time call, hamstring
13Tyler ShoughSaintsB+9.62Yes
14Jacoby BrissettCardinalsB+7.12Yes
15Jared GoffLionsB+6.62Yes
16Deshaun WatsonBrownsB+6.62Yes
17Bo NixBroncosB+5.52Yes
18Tyson BagentBearsB+3.61starts if Williams sits
19Joe BurrowBengalsB+3.42Yes
20Patrick MahomesChiefsB+3.22Yes
21Jayden DanielsCommandersB+2.42out, elbow
22Drake MayePatriotsB+2.22Yes
23Justin HerbertChargersC-1.02Yes
24C.J. StroudTexansC-1.62Yes
25Daniel JonesColtsC-6.62Yes
26Carson WentzVikingsC-7.52backup, Murray cleared
27Baker MayfieldBuccaneersC-8.02Yes
28Malik WillisDolphinsC-8.72Yes
29Cam WardTitansC-9.22Yes
30Marcus MariotaCommandersD-15.81starting for Daniels
31Jordan LovePackersD-17.12Yes
32Aaron RodgersSteelersD-25.42Yes
33Cooper RushFalconsD-40.42backup, Penix starting
34Jameis WinstonGiantsD-61.61starting, Dart out for the season

Click a column to sort. Click again to reverse it, and once more to go back to the original order.

← All posts